The Nursing Journal of India - Effectiveness of Video-Assisted Teaching Module (VATM) on Knowledge regarding Umbilical Cord Blood Stem Cells Banking among Staff Nurses in Selected Hospitals of Odisha

Umbilical cord blood (UCB) was thought of as a waste product of the birthing process before 1970, but now it is valued for the presence of haemopoietic stem cells as an alternative source of bone marrow. In India, there are approximately 72,000 births daily, so also discarding of 72,000 umbilical cords a day. Hence, the so-called waste can be of significant value for human survival and is an abundantly available source of stem cells (Bobak & Jenson, 1995; Waller-Wise, 2011; Steven, 2011; Roura et al, 2015; Peberdy et al, 2018). Stem cells are the basis of the human body and are viewed as the master cells of the body. Blood, bones, skin and muscle tissue are fashioned from the master cells recognised as stem cells that act as constructing blocks of our body. Just like a seed of a plant which offers branches, leaves and fruits, these stem cells can grow into specialised cells of our body, such as blood cells, muscle cells, brain cells and so forth (Vignesh et al, 2017). Among the various sources of stem cells, UCB has proved to be a unique source, providing several advantages over other sources. Most importantly, UCB-derived stem cells are readily available and an be obtained non-invasively during the process of delivery. Moreover, their banking potential adds a lot to their importance for regenerative medicine (Mayani H, 2020). UCB-MSCs therapy may show some positive effect in treating critical COVID-19 to some extent, for its delaying deterioration of the disease and efficacy in respiratory and renal function, though limited (Tao J, et al, 2020).

Objectives
The study was set with following objectives:
1. To assess the existing knowledge of staff nurses regarding UCB stem cell banking.
2. To evaluate the effectiveness of VATM regarding UCB stem cell banking among staff nurses.
3. To find out the association between the posttest knowledge scores of staff nurses and their selected demographic variables.

Need for the study:
UCB contains a large quantity of haematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) that have been used successfully for allogenic transplantation to treat a variety of genetic, haematologic and oncologic disorders. It proves to be a potential alternative when autonomous or allogenic transplantation with HLA-matched marrow is unavailable for children (Paytal et al, 2018).
Therefore, the researchers, being a nurse, were fascinated to carry out the research project regarding UCB stem cells banking among staff nurses as it is felt that exploring existing knowledge and providing education through video to enhance knowledge will be beneficial to the staff nurses in their clinical setting.

Hypotheses:
H01: There is no significant difference between pre-test and post-test knowledge scores of staff nurses regarding UCB stem cell banking.
H02: There is no significant association between post-test knowledge scores of staff nurses regarding UCB stem cell banking with their selected demographic variables.
The conceptual framework of study based on theory of Ludwig von Bertalanffy is shown in Fig 1.

Review of Literature
The literature reviewed for the present study contains general information on stem cells and UCB stem cells banking, existing knowledge of staff nurses on UCB stem cells banking, effect of educational programme on staff nurses’ knowledge regarding UCB stem cell banking and effectiveness of video-assisted teaching module (VATM) on knowledge of staff nurses regarding UCB stem cells banking. Stem cells are unique cells that can be regenerated and transformed into different types of mature and functional cells while maintaining their original identity. This unique ability of stem cells discovered its significance in regenerative medicine and has laid the foundation for cell-based therapies (Mahla, 2016 and National Institutes of Health, 2019).

Umbilical cord blood is a primitive and abundant source of mesenchymal stem cells. UCB-derived MSCs have a broad and efficient therapeutic capacity to treat various diseases and disorders. Despite the high latent self-renewal and differentiation capacity of these cells, the safety, efficacy, and yield of MSCs expanded for ex vivo clinical applications remains a concern (Um S, et al; 2020).
Over 40,000 UCB transplantations have been performed worldwide for the treatment of around 80 medical disorders. Approximately 800,000 UCB units are stored in public banks worldwide, while more than 4 million units are stored in private banks (Mayani H, 2020).
Maternity nurses are an integral part of health care providers in all phases of life. Nurses’ knowledge and attitude regarding umbilical cord blood collection will help to achieve this process successfully. Nurses have a specified role in teaching patients. They have a reliable source of health information, so they must be aware of the latest medical diagnoses and treatment (David M et al, 2020).
Mothers who got information from professional sources did not need additional information. Conversely, mothers who turned to other mothers for information were more likely to desire further information. Most mothers report the Internet as the main source of information. Providing accurate information through official sources may result in a more positive attitude toward donation (Grano C, 2020).
Nurses and midwives are part of health care in all the stages of our lives. Thus, nurses must be knowledgeable and aware of recent trends in diagnosis and treatment. Continuing education provides a means by which nurses can remain up to date with current developments, maintain their competence and meet the standards of nursing practice (Malathi P, 2021).

Materials and Methods
The research approach adopted was quantitative type. It had a preexperimental one group pre-test & post-test design. The study was set in SCB, Medical College & Hospital (MCH), Cuttack (Odisha). Staff nurses working in SCB AMCH Medical College & Hospital, Cuttack constituted the study population.

Sample & sample size: Two hundred staff nurses working in SCB MCH, Cuttack, were selected as samples for the study. However, five staff nurses did not attend pre-test, and another five staff nurses did not attend the post-test.

Sampling technique: Convenience sampling technique was used.

Ethical consideration: Written permission was taken from the authorities, and written consent was taken from the staff nurses. Confidentiality and autonomy were assured.

Research Tools for Data Collection Closed-ended questionnaire has two parts. Part A included demographic data like habitat, age, religion, educational qualification, total experience and experience in the OG department, and sources of knowledge. Part B included multiple-choice questions on UCB.

Validity: The tools after construction were sent to 10 experts from related fields of research for validation.

Reliability: The reliability of the tool was established by testing the internal consistency. The reliability of the questionnaire was tested through the half method. The correlation coefficient was calculated using the Spearman Brown Prophecy formula. The reliability obtained was 0.894, which indicated that the questionnaire is highly reliable to conduct a research study.

Pilot study: After testing the reliability and validity of the research tool, a pilot study was conducted in the 130-bed District Headquarter Hospital, Cuttack, among 30 samples and analysed for feasibility of the main study.

Data Collection Procedure
Step I: The pre-test was conducted at SCB MCH, Cuttack, Odisha, on 1 August 2020. Due to Covid19 pandemic, before collecting data, rooms were selected to make participants comfortable before administering the questionnaire and to avoid contamination of the samples and preventing disturbances in the work schedule of staff nurses; three groups were made with 25-30 staff nurses in one hall and pre-test was conducted in three shifts in a single day. Later, all the questionnaires were collected by the researcher herself. A total of 195 participants attended and submitted filled questionnaires.

Step II: The investigator sent VATM to all participants through their e-mail id; 15 days were given to go through the video, and to contact the investigator and clear the doubts if any queries arise. The majority of participants had doubts about the timing of UCB collection, testing and processing of UCB stem cells and preservation of UCB stem cells. All the doubts of the participants were cleared.

Step III: In the next phase, the post-test was conducted after a week’s interval on 16 August 2020 using the same questionnaire which was used for the pre-test. Nurses available in each shift were interviewed consecutively within three hours. Later, all the questionnaires were collected. In the post-test, 195 staff nurses had attended and submitted filled questionnaires.

After the post-test, the filled-in questionnaires of both the pre-test and post-test were compared. It was found that out of 200 staff nurses, five did not attend the pre-test, and five staff nurses did not attend the post-test. So, they were excluded from the study. Hence, the actual sample size for the present study was 190.

Results Demographic Characteristics The frequency- and percentage-wise distribution of staff nurses is shown in Table 1.

Table 1: Frequency and percentage-wise distribution of staff nurses according to their selected demographic variables (N=190)

Pre-Test Knowledge of Staff Nurses regarding UCBSC Banking

Table 2: Area-wise and overall mean, SD, and mean of pre-test knowledge scores among staff nurses regarding UCB stem cells banking (N=190)

Table 2 reveals that the highest mean score (1.76±1.03) was in the area of ‘preservation of UCBSC’, which is 59 percent of the maximum score. The lowest mean score (1.19±0.77), which is 40 percent of the maximum score was found in the area of ‘Testing and processing of UCBSC’ and the overall pre-test mean score was 16.34±3.46, which is 47 percent of the maximum score, which depicts average level of knowledge score of staff nurses in pre-test.

Comparison of Pre- and Post-Test Knowledge of Staff Nurses regarding UCBSC Banking
It is observed that the increase in the knowledge score varies from around 26 percent to 30 percent for all the areas, except in ‘preservation of UCBSC’ which is only 7 percent, where the pre-test mean was highest (59%), depicting less effectiveness (Table 3 and Fig 2).

Fig. 2 : Cylinder diagram showing percentage of the pre and post-level of knowledge scores

Fig. 2 : Show the differnce in pre and post-level of knowledge staff nurse regarding UCBSC .banking depicting that during pre-test 61.6 percent had averge knowledge and 32.2 percent had poor knowledge. Only 5.3 percent had good knowledge whereas during post-test most (75.8 percent) of the staff nurses had good knowledge and 19.5 percent had excellent knowledge. Only 4.2 percent had average knowledge. It can be interpreted that the improvement in the post-test knowledge on UCBSC, might be due to the effect of VATM. It seems that the VATM was effective in enhancing the knowledge of staff nurses regarding UCBSC banking.

Fig. 3 reveals that pre-test line was above the post-test line in the graph. The difference between pre and post-test curve was highest at Q1, Q2 and Q3 level showing a difference of 8-10 scores which is around 23 percent to 25 percent. Hence, it can be interpreted that the intervention with VATM on UCBSC banking was effective.

Fig 3: O-give curve showing the quartile percentage between pre and post-test knowledge scores.

The line graph shows that thepre-test line is above the post-test line up to 20-22 score whereas the post-test line is above the pre-test line from 22-24 class intervals (Fig 4) The mean score of pre-test was between 14-16 class interval which reveals the post-test mean was 10 score higher when compared to pre-test. Hence, it can be interpreted that the intervention with VATM on UCBSC banking was effective.

Table 3: Paired ‘t’ test to assess the effect of VATM on UCBSC banking among staff nurses (N=190)

Fig 4: Line graph showing comparison of pre and posttest knowledge scores. 

Assessment of Level of Significance of Intervention of VATM on knowledge

Paired ‘t’ test was calculated to find out significant difference within group test scores among staff nurses revealed that there was a highly statistically significant difference between pre-and post-test knowledge scores in all the areas, whereas, there was a highly significant difference outcome scores between pre-test (4.83 ± 1.50) and post-test (8.70 ±1.28) with mean difference 3.24 and obtained ‘t’ value 28.77 with p<0.001 found in the areas of ‘collection’ (Table 3). However, there was a highly statistically significant difference outcome scores between pre-test (1.76 ± 1.03) and post-test (1.98 ±0.69) with lowest mean difference 0.53 and the obtained ‘t’ value 10.89 with p<0.001 found in the areas of ‘Preservation’.

It can be interpreted that overall, all the areas had highly statistically significant differences found between pre-test and post-test. Hence, the null hypothesis is rejected, and the alternative hypothesis is accepted indicating that VATM was highly effective in improving the knowledge of staff nurses on UCBSC banking.

Assessment of Association between Post-Test Knowledge Scores and Selected Demographic Variables

Association between post-test knowledge score and selected demographic variables shows that the level of knowledge had no significant association for all demographic variables Table 4. Hence, it can be interpreted that VATM was highly effective irrespective of the differences in the demographic characteristics.

The two- way analysis of co-variance (ANCOVA) for the interaction effect between post-test knowledge (dependent variable) and demographic variables (independent variables) when adjusted the pre intervention knowledge (covariate) (F-value) reveal that there was no statistically significant difference between adjusted means at 0.05 level of significant (p>0.001)(Table-5).

Table 4: Association between level of knowledge in post-test and selected demographic data (N=190)

Table 5: Two-way univariate ANCOVA–Knowledge between subjects’ effects

Discussion
In the present study, the majority (36.84%) of staff nurses were in the age group of 31-40 years. It is similar to the findings of Ibrahim (2019), who revealed that 47 percnt of the nurses were 31-40 years old with a mean of 31.68±5.92 years. Further, the highest percentage (32.11%) had 1-5 years of experience, and the highest percentage (55.79%) of staff nurses had 1-5 years’ experience in the O & G department. It is in contrast to the report of Mansour et al (2020), who found that 50 percent of them had 6 to 10 years of experience with a mean of 8.73 ± 2.81 years. The overall mean was 16.34±3.46, which is 47 percent in the pre-test, whereas it was 25.78±3.05, which is 74 percent in the post-test, and the difference is 27 percent. It seems that before intervention, the score was lower in all the areas except preservation of UCBSC. The findings are congruent with those of Mohammed & Sayed (2015), who revealed that 88.7 percent of nurses had poor knowledge before intervention. The calculated chi-square value shows that there is no significant association between posttest knowledge scores and all selected demographic variables. This shows that VATM was highly effective irrespective of the differences in the demographic characteristics. Findings are contrary to the study by Amira & Sabah (2016), who found that there was a statistically significant correlation between PICU nurses’ total awareness with their age as when the age increase the nurses’ knowledge will in turn increase.

Study implications: This study has significant implications in nursing practice, administration, education and research.

Recommendation A comparative study and a true experimental study can be conducted to assess the knowledge and practice regarding UCB stem cell banking among healthcare professionals.

Conclusion
Most of the staff nurses have average knowledge regarding an umbilical cord blood stem cells banking. The possible reason can be the lack of pre-service and in-service education on stem cells and umbilical cord blood banking. The study recommends formal training of staff nurses regarding UCB stem cell banking.

References

1. Ammu J, Abirami P. Effectiveness of video-assisted teaching module on utilization of placental stem cells. Emer Life Sci Res 2016; 2 (2): 13-20

2. Bobak & Jenson. Maternity and Gynecology Care. 5th edn, 1995. New York: Mosby Publishers, pp 32-38

3. Barker JN, Wagner JE. Umbilical cord blood transplantation: Current practice and future innovations. Critical Reviews in Oncology/ Hematology 2003; 48 (1): 35-43

4. Dinç H, Sahin NH. Pregnant women’s knowledge and attitudes about stem cells and cord blood banking. Int Nurs Rev 2009; 56 (2): 250-56

5. Paytal N, Kaur R, Singh Ravnoorpreet, Arushi, Reetu, Ridhim, et al. A study to assess the knowledge and attitude of nurses regarding stem cell and umbilical cord blood banking in selected hospitals of Ambala, Haryana. Pharma Innovation Journal 2018; 7(6): 154-59

6. Peberdy L, Young J, Massey DL, Kearney L. Parents’ knowledge, awareness and attitudes of cord blood donation and banking options: An integrative review. J BMC Pregnancy Childbirth 2018; 18(1): 395

7. Roura S, Pujal JM, Montón CG, Genis AB. The role and potential of umbilical cord blood in an era of new therapies: A review. Stem Cell Res Ther 2015; 6(1): 123

8. Waller-Wise R. Umbilical cord blood: Information for childbirth educators. J Perinatal Educ 2011; 20(1): 54–60

9. Vignesh D, Vanishree N, Anushri M, Narayan R, Raveendran MP. Pregnant women’s knowledge and attitude towards the role of stem cells in dentistry. A crosssectional study. Indian Journal of Oral Health Res 2017; 3: 57-61


Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.